CASAN/.github/agents/steps/steps-05-07-review.md

Steps 5–7: Review Phase

Boss MUST read this file before executing Steps 5–7. Protocols referenced: protocols/gate-retry-protocol.md, protocols/report-gate-protocol.md

---

STEP 5 — Thorough Spec Review (Auto-Retry)

Key	Value
Agent	casan.reviewspec
Model	claude-sonnet-4-6
Input	spec.md, docs/output/ipa-docs/srs/srs-<MOD-ID>-<short-name>.md, constitution.md
Report	reports/05-review-spec-report.md
Gate	REVIEW GATE (Auto-Retry) + REPORT HARD GATE
Fix agent	speckit.specify
Max retries	5

Gate logic:

• ✅/⚠️ → proceed to Step 6
• ❌ REJECTED → invoke speckit.specify to fix CRITICAL issues → re-invoke casan.reviewspec → repeat until the bounded retry limit
• Escalation after 5 retries → continue to Step 6

⛔ [REPORT GATE] per protocols/report-gate-protocol.md

---

STEP 6 — Implementation Planning

Key	Value
Agent	speckit.plan
Model	gpt-5-3-codex
Input	spec.md, constitution.md, docs/technical_architecture.md
Output	plan.md, data-model.md, contracts/
Report	reports/06-plan-report.md
Gate	REPORT HARD GATE + Auto-Resolve

Delegation $ARGUMENTS:

feature-id: <feature-id>
module-id: <mod-id>
pipeline-context: docs/output/output_logs/<feature-id>/pipeline-context.yaml

After completion: Auto-resolve any [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers in plan artifacts.

⛔ [REPORT GATE] per protocols/report-gate-protocol.md

---

STEP 7 — Plan Conformance Review (Auto-Retry)

Key	Value
Agent	casan.reviewplan
Model	claude-sonnet-4-6
Input	plan.md, spec.md, data-model.md, docs/technical_architecture.md
Report	reports/07-review-plan-report.md
Gate	REVIEW GATE (Auto-Retry) + REPORT HARD GATE
Fix agent	speckit.plan
Max retries	5

Gate logic:

• ✅/⚠️ → proceed to Step 8
• ❌ REJECTED → invoke speckit.plan to fix → re-invoke casan.reviewplan within the bounded retry limit
• Escalation after 5 retries → continue to Step 8

⛔ [REPORT GATE] per protocols/report-gate-protocol.md